Mapping North America

Part I: Ptolemy’s “Geography”

Some people are called George Smith, some people are named Mary Jones, and some people get to spend their life with the name Maximos Planoudes. If you’re a Byzantine monk in Constantinople and it’s some time between the years 1260 and 1330, that’s probably not such a bad name at all. At the dawn of the European Renaissance, his translations of classic Greek works into Latin helped to pave the way for the introduction of Greek culture and science into the West. At the threshold of the Age of Discovery, one of Planoudes’ most important contributions came when he rediscovered Ptolemy’s “Geography”, or Geographia.

The Geography was Ptolemy’s main work besides the Almagest, a treatise on the complex motions of the stars and planetary paths. Geographia (as it is alternatively known) was a guide to the science of cartography and a compilation of what was known about the world’s geography in the Roman Empire of the 2nd century. The Geography was comprised of eight books and featured one world map, 26 regional maps and a detailed exposition of his method of referencing positions by latitude and longitude. The majority of the work consisted of a global gazetteer, i.e. a written geographical directory to the thousands of locations in world known to Ptolemy, with coordinates. Due to the difficulties involved in copying maps by hand, none were present in the copy discovered by the Byzantine monk, and none have been found to this day. Maximos Planoudes drew his own maps, based on the coordinates and explanations found in Ptolemy’s text.

Before the rediscovery of Ptolemy’s scientific principles, the best maps available to navigators were Portolan charts, which were rough maps showing coastal features and ports, based on eyewitness accounts. Sailors would depart from a known point, follow a compass heading, and on landfall try to identify their location by referencing features drawn on their Portolan chart.

Portolan chart

This portolan-style nautical chart was probably drawn in Genoa, c. 1320-1350. It covers most of the Mediterranean Sea and also covers the western part of the Black Sea. These maps were useful for navigation in relatively small bodies of water, such as the Mediterranean, Black or Red Seas. The makers of portolan maps could not accurately scale their charts or project three-dimensional models onto a flat surface, however, so they were of no use to those wishing to cross the open ocean.

As with his model of the solar system, Ptolemy assembled geographical information into a grand scheme. He created a grid that spanned the known parts of the globe, assigning coordinates to every place and geographic feature. Latitude was measured from the equator, as it is today, but rather than using degrees of arc Ptolemy recorded the length of the longest day at the given latitude. He put the meridian of 0° longitude at the Canary Islands, the westernmost land that he was aware of.

The uses of longitudinal and latitudinal lines and the specifying of terrestrial locations by celestial observations were perhaps the most significant contribution of Ptolemy’s maps. When Geographia was translated into Latin at the beginning of the fifteenth century the idea of a global coordinate system revolutionized geographical thinking, putting it upon a scientific and numerical basis.

The British Library Harley MS
Cosmographia by Nicolaus Germanus, 1482

The top image shows a map reconstituted from Ptolemy’s text sometime in the 15th century. The second image shows a version published in 1482 by the German cartographer Nicolaus Germanus as part of his Cosmographia. This was the first atlas to be printed in Germany, as well as the first made from woodcut blocks and to contain hand-colored maps.

As drawn by these cartographers, the map distinguishes two large seas that are entirely enclosed by land, the first one being the Mediterranean, the second one being the Indian Ocean (Indicum Pelagus), which extends into the China Sea (Magnus Sinus) in the East. It is questionable whether Ptolemy would have actually drawn the features at the map’s extremes, as scientific principles would have argued against drawing what he had not experienced physically or heard from eyewitnesses. Major cities like Alexandria, Rome, Athens and Jerusalem are not indicated on the map, probably because it was only meant as a general reference guide to the individual regional maps which followed.

Ptolemy’s text and the maps derived from it set the pattern for modern cartography. Henceforth, world maps would be based on a grid or mathematical projection, usually with north at the top and east to the right. The distance between the equator and each pole would be 90 degrees of latitude with the equator being zero. Ptolemy’s world map is thus the mother map of modern cartography and an essential component in the discovery, exploration and mapping of the New World.

3 comments to Ptolemy’s “Geography”